Stadium: Shirk Field at Musselman Stadium Round: 1
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2022/10/01 17:00 | Muhlenberg Mules v Gettysburg Bullets | L | 56-17 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2021/10/02 17:00 | Gettysburg Bullets v Muhlenberg Mules | L | 19-54 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2019/11/09 18:00 | Gettysburg Bullets v Muhlenberg Mules | L | 3-44 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2018/11/03 17:00 | Muhlenberg Mules v Gettysburg Bullets | L | 49-0 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2023/10/06 23:00 | Johns Hopkins Blue Jays v Gettysburg Bullets | L | 49-28 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2023/09/30 17:00 | Mcdaniel Green Terror v Gettysburg Bullets | W | 20-27 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2023/09/16 20:00 | Christopher Newport Captains v Gettysburg Bullets | L | 49-17 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2023/09/09 18:00 | Gettysburg Bullets v Montclair State Red Hawks | L | 21-32 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2023/09/02 17:00 | Gettysburg Bullets v Juniata Eagles | W | 40-20 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2022/11/12 18:00 | Gettysburg Bullets v Franklin And Marshall Diplomats | L | 14-31 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2022/11/05 17:00 | Mcdaniel Green Terror v Gettysburg Bullets | L | 19-16 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2022/10/29 17:00 | Gettysburg Bullets v Ursinus Bears | L | 16-51 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2023/10/07 18:00 | Muhlenberg Mules v Mcdaniel Green Terror | W | 50-6 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2023/09/29 23:00 | Ursinus Bears v Muhlenberg Mules | W | 20-28 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2023/09/16 16:00 | New Jersey v Muhlenberg Mules | W | 10-38 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2023/09/09 16:00 | Muhlenberg Mules v Salisbury Sea Gulls | W | 29-17 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2023/09/01 23:00 | Muhlenberg Mules v Moravian Greyhounds | W | 53-12 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2022/11/12 17:00 | Moravian Greyhounds v Muhlenberg Mules | W | 10-37 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2022/11/05 17:00 | Muhlenberg Mules v Susquehanna River Hawks | L | 24-28 |
| NCAA Division I, FCS, Playoffs | 2022/10/29 17:00 | Muhlenberg Mules v Franklin And Marshall Diplomats | W | 28-21 |